The four causes of behavior: Aristotle and Skinner
نویسنده
چکیده
This article deals with an application of Aristotle’s four causes, the material, the formal, the efficient, and the final causes. Based on an initial systematic application, a new application is proposed in which some previously unconsidered aspects of Aristotle are developed. According to this new application, the material cause would be found in the organism as a whole (and not just in neurobiological substrates), the formal cause would be the prior model on which a certain cause is based (and not an internal representation or a formal analogy of behavior), the efficient cause would be conceived as an agent (and not only an antecedent event), and the final cause would be the teleological function of the behavior. The main implications of this review of the four causes are consolidation of the analysis of behavior on the molar plane of an organism (with no “neuroscientific” reductionisms), establishment of the notion of the person as the origin of behavior (without resorting to the mechanicism of “private events”), and the possible consideration of a radically human behaviorism that would place behavior at the center of the historicalcultural context (not as dependent on laboratory analysis of animal behavior).
منابع مشابه
Aristotle on the Cause of Being and of Coming to Be
This paper considers Aristotle’s distinction between the cause of being and the cause of coming to be. It is intended to show that Aristotle is able to unify both kinds of causes on the basis of the idea that a thing’s substance is its end. He is not confused about the cause of being and of coming to be, as it might seem in several passages. The paper’s focus is on Metaphysics Zeta 17. In contr...
متن کاملReaction of Different Pepper Cultivars to Two Species of Root- Knot Nematodes (M. Javanica and M. Incognita)
Root knot nematode is one of the important plant pathogens that causes damage to many crops, including greenhouse crops. Pepper is an agricultural crop which its cultivation has increased in recent years, especially in greenhouses. Most of the adopted management methods for this nematode have not met the required efficiency. In this study, reaction of some pepper cultivars (Elmina, Tuvana, Chal...
متن کاملAristotle on Principles as Elements
In his discussion of the four causes, Aristotle claims that ‘the hypotheses are material causes of the conclusion’ (Physics 2. 3, Metaphysics Δ 2). This claim has puzzled commentators since antiquity. It is usually taken to mean that the premisses of any deduction are material causes of the conclusion. By contrast, I argue that the claim does not apply to deductions in general but only to scien...
متن کاملThe Four Causes of Behavior.
Comprehension of a phenomenon involves identifying its origin, structure, substrate, and function, and representing these factors in some formal system. Aristotle provided a clear specification of these kinds of explanation, which he called efficient causes (triggers), formal causes (models), material causes (substrates or mechanisms), and final causes (functions). In this article, Aristotle's ...
متن کاملSuccessful management of an equine carpal chip fracture by intra-articularly injected adipose-derived stromal vascular fraction after arthroscopic removal
Carpal chip fractures are common causes of lameness in racehorses. Due to disadvantages in surgical management, adjuvant treatment modalities are usually necessary. Adipose-derived stem cells (ADSCs) have the potential to differentiate into other cell types including bone and cartilage cells. Adipose-derived stromal vascular fraction (SVF) is produced during ADSCs isolation from adipose tissue....
متن کامل